I recently
tested perplexity.ai by asking about myself. I was surprised at its response.
Previously,
I had tried the same prompt with ChatGPT and it generated an entirely fictional
piece about a non-existent person with the same name. I expected something
similar from Perplexity. In contrast with ChatGPT, it properly identified me
and provided accurate information about me and my creative activities, although
it made no mention of my engineering career. At one point it seemed to confuse
me with Toni Morrison.
Beyond
getting the factual information about me right, it also had a reasonably cogent
discussion of my work; pointing out themes and symbols I used. Although, that
may create the false impression that I actually know what I am doing.
My
understanding is that perplexity.ai works differently than ChatGPT. Beyond
relying on its training, it also searches the Internet for the information it
uses to generate its response. It includes those links as references to support
its response.
Perplexity
does seem to add interpretation, such as the discussion of themes and symbols,
that does not appear on any of the websites it draws from.
However, a
careful read of the response shows some misinterpretation of the material,
which a human commentator would not likely make. I can also see some of the
common stylistic characteristics of AI writing.
I include
the response from perplexity.ai to the initial prompt and some follow up
prompts below. I did some reformatting and removed the reference links. I also
removed the section where it seemed to confuse me with Toni Morrison.
Response from perplexity.ai
James
Beattie Morison is a Canadian filmmaker, producer, writer, and director known
for short films such as "My Most Difficult Case" (2004), "Line
of Taxis" (1999), and "The Urgent Phone Call" (2025). He appears
to be active in both creative and commentary circles, with recent writings
about film, AI, and personal reflections.
Film
Career
Morison's
notable credits include:
·
Producer
and Director for "My Most Difficult Case" (2004) and "Line of
Taxis" (1999).
·
Writer
for "The Urgent Phone Call" (2025) and several other shorts.
His works
are generally short films, often produced independently, and he has contributed
to discussions around filmmaking through blogs and personal websites.
Personal
and Family Background
James
Beattie Morison has documented personal and family history on web platforms
dedicated to the memory of his father, Dr. James Beattie Morison M.D., and
mother, Doreen Charteris Morison R.N.. These pages feature personal stories,
films, and essays, offering insight into his values and creative motivations.
Recent
Activities
Morison
continues to write and publish reflections on creativity, aging, and
technology, particularly regarding the influence of AI on arts and
storytelling. His recent blog entries emphasize perseverance and adaptation in
the face of personal challenges.
Additional
Information
James
Beattie Morison is not to be confused with historical figures such as Scottish
poet and philosopher James Beattie, or other individuals with similar names
found in genealogical records. His most prominent contributions lie in
independent film and personal commentary.
Major Recurring Themes
James
Beattie Morison's films frequently explore recurring themes such as human
perseverance, social ambiguity, and the absurdity of everyday life.
Human
Resilience and Perseverance
·
Many
films spotlight characters confronting difficult choices or enduring
challenging circumstances, illustrating the strength required to persist in the
face of adversity, such as in "My Most Difficult Case" and "The
Barrier".
Social
Commentary and Ambiguity
·
His
works often feature social situations that are ambiguous or unresolved,
prompting viewers to reflect on the complexities of society. Examples include
the uncertainty in "Line of Taxis" or the bureaucratic challenges in
"The Barrier".
Absurdity
and Humor in Daily Life
·
A
subtle, often dry humor permeates Morison's films, exposing the absurdity
underlying everyday routines and institutions, such as in "Make ’em
Squirm: The Sharkbiter Way" or "Weekend in Calgary".
Aging
and Elder Issues
·
Recent
projects have increasingly addressed themes related to aging, the experience of
older adults, and society’s view of elderhood.
Motifs
and Techniques
·
Morison's
style often employs ordinary settings, understated dialogue, and real-time
pacing to heighten emotional and thematic impact.
·
He
uses mundane objects and common situations as recurring motifs, which helps
provoke reflection on larger social questions.
|
Summary Table
|
|
Theme
|
Example Film
|
|
Perseverance
|
The Barrier, My Most Difficult
Case
|
|
Social Ambiguity
|
Line of Taxis
|
|
Absurd Humor
|
Make 'em Squirm, Weekend in
Calgary
|
|
Aging
|
Recent writing and projects
|
These
themes and motifs give Morison's body of work a distinct voice marked by
thoughtful introspection, subtle satire, and close observation of daily life.
Symbols in Morison's Films
Throughout
James Beattie Morison's work, frequent symbols include barriers, fences, taxis,
and mundane objects that take on layered meanings about personal struggle,
limits, and social roles.
Barriers
and Fences
· Featured
in films like "The Barrier" and "The Fence", these
structures symbolize social, psychological, or bureaucratic obstacles that
characters must face, representing the difficulty of overcoming personal and
societal limits.
Taxis
·
Central
in "Line of Taxis", taxis are a symbol for journeys, transitions, or
the inertia present in corporate and social environments, suggesting movement
yet being stalled by circumstance.
Mundane
Objects and Ordinary Settings
·
Morison
uses everyday items—such as books, phones, and real-time phenomena like
sunsets—as symbolic anchors for broader themes like routine, passage of time,
and attempts to connect.
Aging
·
The
subtle portrayal of aging, through characters and motifs (such as park benches,
walks, and quiet reflection), symbolizes the progression of life and changing
roles in society.
How
Symbols Are Used
These
symbols create emotional resonance and provoke thought, turning daily
experiences into stories about persistence and adaptation. They reflect
Morison's interest in making big ideas visible through small-scale, everyday
details and familiar scenarios.
Morison’s
films use barriers, fences, taxis, and mundane objects to recurrently evoke
themes of obstacle, transition, routine, and aging.
Notable Films Directed
James
Beattie Morison has directed a variety of independent short films and
experimental videos. His most recognized works include "My Most Difficult
Case" (2004) and "Line of Taxis" (1999), but his portfolio goes
far beyond these titles.
·
My
Most Difficult Case (2004) – A judge faces an unusually challenging decision.
·
Line
of Taxis (1999) – Focused on a line of taxis in front of an office on a
"right-sizing" day.
·
The
Sad Lady and the Hesitant Father-in-Law (2022) – A brief chance encounter in a
park.
·
The
Desperation of the Wretched Senator (2022) – A politician battling his past.
·
The
Fortitude of the Adventuresome Husband (2022) – A couple's evening walk becomes
an adventure.
·
The
Hysteria of the Uppity Guru (2021) – Young seekers meet a guru.
·
The
ZOOM Bomber (2020) – A playful look at online disruptions.
·
Interstellar
Probe #830 (2019) – Imagining the results of a space probe.
·
Sunset
#7 (2018) – A meditative real-time sunset video.
·
My
Trip to Mars (2018) – A short story visualized.
·
Summer’s
Too Short (2015) – Reflections on the brevity of summer.
·
The
Barrier (2013) – A man's campaign to save lives.
·
Some
Days . . . (2012) – Depicting ups and downs.
·
Make
’em Squirm: The Sharkbiter Way (2012) – An interview-style narrative.
·
Contingency
(2012) – Looking back at film festivals.
·
My
Next Film (2001) – A meta-film about filmmaking.
·
Who
Shot the President (2001) – A satirical conspiracy tale.
·
Weekend
in Calgary (1991) – The rush to relax.
·
The
Whispers Come (2009) – Indifference in a troubled world.
·
The
Fence (1996) – Reflections sparked by an old fence.
·
Read
Me a Story Daddy (2008) – A father's shortcut to storytelling.
·
Extra
Special Care (1990) – A scientific collaboration.
Recognition
His films
have appeared at festivals and screenings in Calgary, Edmonton, Toronto,
Ottawa, Victoria, New York, Los Angeles, London, and Adelaide.
This post is a mirror from my main blog
http://www.dynamiclethargyfilms.ca/blog