Showing posts with label writing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label writing. Show all posts

Sunday, September 1, 2024

Ideas for Older People Films


I have been involved with the Calgary Society of Independent Filmmaker’s (CSIF) Older Filmmakers Club for a few years now. (https://csif.org/clubs/) We have been talking about the issues we would like to address in our films. Of course, we do not want to focus exclusively on issues that older people face, but we do want to emphasis elder issues.

This blog post is a preliminary list of issues that could form the spark for story ideas. You will notice that I have a dearth of upbeat issues. The essence of drama is conflict, so that tends to focus more on downbeat issues. If you have any suggestions for upbeat ideas, please comment.

Many of these issues could become cautionary tales for people as they age.

Social Isolation and loneliness

It is a sad fact that as we grow older, we lose friends and family to death and distance. Live changes, such as retirement, cut us off from other people. This topic does have the potential for an upbeat story about how someone overcomes the isolation in their life.

I have tried to write a short script based on this sense of loss and isolation. I was not happy with how it turned out.

Reconnecting with old friends and family

When you are younger, and life is busy with work, many people tend to neglect friends and family. Sometimes, you will even lose touch with them. Later in life, though, people find the time to reconnect with old friends.

In my own life, it was joining Facebook that allowed me to reconnect with people I had not talked to since high school. This is the opposite of the problem of social isolation.

Ageism and Discrimination

As we grow older, we become more confident in our abilities. But there comes a time when younger people no longer appreciate what we can do. It comes as a shock when other people do not value our contributions as much as when we were younger.

Elder Abuse

This is an incredibly sad situation for the people who face it. It is something that many people fear as they grow older and become more reliant on others. Stories about people facing abuse can be like a horror movie. It can truly be a life-or-death situation that people can find themselves in.

Financial Insecurity

Some older people have built up the savings and assets they need to live comfortably. Many have not. With a fixed income and an inability to earn more money through taking on new jobs, they worry about their finances. Often older people stop working because they are no longer able to work.

Facing Retirement

Retirement is a major life changing event. It can be either an escape to freedom or the end of an important part of someone’s life.

I have heard personal stories of people who had a plan for their retirement during their working years. It gave them a goal to work toward. But it sometimes turns into a sad story. After years of looking forward, the reality of their plan is a disappointment. After only a few months of retirement, their experiences and disappointments force them to rethink their life goals.

Someone wise told me several years before I retired, suggested I take a leave of absence from work and do a practice retirement. This experience was valuable and helped me focus better on planning my retirement.

Lost Sense of Purpose

Another effect of retirement and growing old is losing your sense of purpose. When you were younger, you had things you had to do every day and things you wanted to do every day. In old age, many people no longer have the same needs and desires.

Declining health

As we age, we face many heath issues: arthritis, cognitive decline, dementia, diabetes, hearing loss, vision loss, heart disease, mental health problems, and osteoporosis are common problems. These can be disheartening and prevent us from doing the things we want to do.

Relationships with Medical Staff

There is a point when you start to see a doctor that is younger than you. Growing up you see doctors as someone to look up to. When the time comes, as it will eventually, when you are seeing someone younger than you for your medical needs, it can be a difficult experience to work through.

I worked on a story about an active older man who, because of a life-threatening issue, becomes confined to his bed. His family hire a younger woman to be his care giver. At first, he resents her as just some kid telling him what to do, but as time goes on, they develop a respect and a deep bond for each other. I gave up on it because it was beyond my skill as a writer to write with such emotional depth. I still feel the idea still has potential, but I don’t feel I could pull it off.

Difficulty with Everyday Tasks and Mobility

Problems with balance, coordination, frailty, and loss of strength can lead to a greater risk of falls and impose limits on what a person can do in life.

I had an experience when I was younger, where I saw an older woman fall on the street and hurt herself. I stayed with her. Someone said they would call an ambulance, but none ever came. At first, she was confused, but eventually became quite lucid. Despite my concerns she insisted she was OK. She wanted to go to a nearby church, so I helped her over there and left her at the entry. It has been over 40 years, and I still feel that I let her down.

That personal story is still too raw for me to explore in a story, but I am sure that others can create stories that deal with the same issues.

Loss of Independence

I felt that the woman who fell was worried about losing her independence if her family learned of her fall. This is a fear that haunts all of us as we age.

Housing

In the later parts of life, people frequently must leave their homes to move into more supportive housing. These can be normal apartments that focus on retired people but can range through more intensive types of nursing homes, and eventually hospice care. The transition to these other types of housing can be a challenge. The transition may include the stress of downsizing and letting go of cherished keepsakes. It may include adjusting to a new lifestyle with new limitations on what people can do.

When I was young, in the early 1960s, one of my father’s responsibilities was to inspect what people then called Old Folks Homes. He wrote a couple of papers about what he learned from that experience. Things have changed since then, but the transitions people go through can still be fraught with conflict.

·         https://dynamiclethargy.ca/jm09.htm

·         https://dynamiclethargy.ca/Color_and_Warmth.pdf

Adjusting to Changes in Society

Society does change over time. Things that were acceptable in our youth are no longer acceptable and things that were not acceptable, are now acceptable. People react to these changes in diverse ways. Some people accept change. Some people reject change. Some people embrace change. Others understand the need for change, but struggle to accept it. Some changes are serious and important, while others are trivial.

Adjusting to New Technology

Like society in general, technology changes as we grow older. One example is the Internet. It has created many opportunities, for both good and evil. The changes have been hard for some people to adapt to.

Loss of Loved Ones and Dealing with Grief

As we age, so do our friends and family. Most, if not all, of us will experience the death of someone important in our lives. Going through these events can be difficult. Stories of how people deal with death and grief can be valuable for others who face those same challenges.

End-of-Life Planning

We all know that someday we will die, but most people find it hard to think about. It is wise to discuss our plans for our death long before the time is imminent. It is much harder to talk these things over when the end is approaching.

I wrote a short movie script based on conversations with my wife leading up to her death. While it was cathartic for me to work through those emotions, I was not comfortable going forward with the project.

Since it is something that people need to think about, many people would appreciate a story that explores the challenges of end-of-life planning.

 

This is a preliminary list that I hope will spark some film projects. If you have any suggestions for other relevant issues, please comment.

If you are interested in the CSIF’s Older Filmmaker’s Club, you can e-mail them at theolderfilmmakersclub@gmail.com.



This post is a mirror from my main blog http://www.dynamiclethargyfilms.ca/blog

Sunday, May 5, 2024

Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Me – Part 3 - Drawbacks, and Dangers

 

I intended to talk about some of the negative and positive aspects of Artificial Intelligence in this post. However, I decided that the positives and opportunities of AI deserved a more thorough examination. I will do a separate post on those later.

The focus of my post will be on the use of AI in creative work. There are issues in other areas of AI application that I won’t get into.

AI Has No Emotion or Motivation

“Well, he acts like he has genuine emotions. Um, of course he's programmed that way to make it easier for us to talk to him. But as to whether he has real feelings is something I don't think anyone can truthfully answer.” Dave Bowman talking about HAL 9000 in the movie “2001: A Space Odyssey.

Having watched the movie about 30 or 40 times, I think it is meant to be a question that is asked but not answered, but one that the audience is meant to ponder. Does HAL really have emotion, or are his actions just a flaw in his programming?

We have the same question about the real-world AIs we have today. Based on my reading and experience so far, I don’t think current AIs have either emotions or motivation. Maybe someday they will.

In many applications of AI, emotions and motivations are not important. But, when we call on AIs to be creative, emotions and motivations are critical.

In my own experience, and in the opinions I’ve heard from other people, stories written by AIs tend to be bland. They tend toward clichés and lack emotion. That sort of thing is OK in some contexts, like business or technical writing, but it just doesn’t work in creative writing.

Writers, and other creative people are driven to create. No one needs to prompt them. They pour their emotions into their work. That is what makes the art they create interesting to other people.

None of the existing AIs can be described as self-starters. They only react when prompted. They are not motivated to do anything. Left to themselves, they would do nothing. AIs do not want anything. They have no desires.

Homogenization of Content

I came across this idea several times. AIs that generate writing are based on the likelihood that a given word would be followed by another word. This results in writing that hews toward the most common expression. As noted by some, AIs are cliché machines. They don’t go for the unusual, they go for the common.

The trend for the future is toward more homogenized writing. As more of the writing available for training AIs is created by other AIs, less common expressions will be driven out of use. Bland writing from AIs will become blander.

False Hopes for an Easy Writing Career

I’ve seen several articles and YouTube videos claiming that you can be a successful writer using AIs.

I suspect that is unrealistic.

Mostly it is because few writers are successful. The average traditionally published book may only have 3,000 in total sales. With some books selling millions, that means that most books will sell much less than 3,000 copies. Self-published books average only 250 in total sales. (see: https://scribemedia.com/book-sales/)

In my own case, the book I published sold three copies and I made $2.87. It is still for sale if you’d like to bump up my sales to four copies. https://www.lulu.com/shop/james-morison/walk-in-the-snow-a-collection-of-stories-and-articles/ebook/product-1m4ermrp.html

Aside from the low returns on publishing in general, I doubt that many people would want to buy an AI generated book. Nowadays, anyone who wants to, can generate their own AI story, so why pay for someone else’s AI story.

I think that people may well want to generate AI stories, not to sell, but to read themselves. It is already possible to have AI generate a story to your personal specification. You can have a novel where you are the hero.

I haven’t gone to that extent myself, but I have used ChatGPT to create short stories for my own entertainment. I expect that I am not the only one who has done this. While I did get some enjoyment from this, the experience didn’t give me much encouragement about the future of creative writing with AI.

Wrestling with AI

When I experimented with systems like ChatGPT, I find myself fighting with the system to get it to write what I want. In the end, I go back to just writing it myself. If you have something you want to say, or want to say something in a specific way, working with large language models can be very frustrating.

I’m not sure that this limitation will go away any time soon. It may not be a problem if you do not care what is generated, but that isn’t something that happens often.

AI Generated Voices

Many text to voice systems have been used to create audiobooks and YouTube videos. These have the same problem of blandness and lack of emotion as AI writing systems. The reaction to these is often quite negative.

I have used text to voice systems myself in some of my projects. While I have tried some tricks to give the voices a little more character, I still had negative feedback from people. While these voices have improved, they still have that same lack of emotion and blandness that pales compared to the humanity of real actors.

If You Want to be a Writer, Why Would You Use AI?

“I write for the same reason I breathe … because if I didn’t, I would die.” - Isaac Asimov

I read another comment from Isaac Asimov that if you want to be a writer you must enjoy the act of writing. He went on to emphasis that he meant sitting at the keyboard and bleeding your ideas onto paper. (note: this was from the pre home computer days).

I write, and do the other creative activities I do, because I want to do them. Using AI to write stories for me would be like sending an AI assistant to watch a movie I want to see.



This post is a mirror from my main blog http://www.dynamiclethargyfilms.ca/blog

Sunday, January 15, 2023

ChatGPT Test

There has been a lot of discussion of how Artificial Intelligence systems, like ChatGPT, will change the world. After prompting from several people, I decided to try ChatGPT.

What I wanted to test was whether an AI system, like ChapGPT, could be a useful tool in my writing and movie making. I’m looking at ChatGPT as something that might help me write. I am not looking at it as something that would create stories I want to read.

I’ve been doing a series of writing exercises based on a random title prompt. My plan was to give ChatGPT one of the prompts I had used recently. I chose “The Old House and the Desperate Baroness.” I’d posted a new recording of it last week: https://soundcloud.com/dynamiclethargy/the-old-house-and-the-desperate-baroness-1

I gave ChatGPT the prompt:

Write a 500-word story with the title "The Old House and the Desperate Baroness.”

It took about a minute to produce the short story, which ended up being 561 words long. I turned it into a recording using a computer-generated voice. I thought that would appropriate. "The Old House and the Desperate Baroness” by ChatGPT

I was impressed that the story was coherent and an easy read. It wasn’t the kind of story that I would have written. I like my story better. My story had a bit of a sad end for the baroness, while ChatGPT gave her a happy ending. I wanted a story with some dialogue, but this story had none.

I decided to ask ChatGPT to write a script, so I gave it the prompt:

Write a 5-page film script with the title "The Old House and the Desperate Baroness.”

It refused. This was its response:

I'm sorry, I am not able to write a 5-page film script at this time. My capabilities are better suited for providing concise and accurate information or answering questions. If you need assistance in creating a script, I recommend consulting a professional screenwriter or utilizing script-writing software.

I think there is more to learn about how to use ChatGPT. I suspect that the creativity in the stories it writes must come from the prompt you give it.

I would like to try giving it an outline for a story. I have several projects where I am stuck at the outline stage and need to do some more research before I can write the stories. I wonder if ChatGPT can do that for me. I would expect that all I would get would be a first draft that I would need to rewrite.

More generally, I think that the limitation of artificial intelligence systems is that unlike people, they don’t want anything. They can only react to a prompt or command.

I talked about Artificial Intelligence in some previous blog posts.

·         http://dynamiclethargyfilms.ca/joi-and-virtual-john/

·         https://dynamiclethargyfilms.ca/setting-priorities-for-2020/



This post is a mirror from my main blog http://www.dynamiclethargyfilms.ca/blog